When a Criterion Collection DVD goes out of print, it becomes more than just unavailable—it transforms into a piece of cinematic history. These editions are known for their high-quality transfers, rare bonus features, and thoughtful packaging, making them prized possessions for collectors and film lovers alike.
But tracking down these titles—especially in good condition—can be challenging. That’s where this guide comes in: to help you understand why certain Criterion DVDs become collector gems, how to identify them, and where to find them.
Do you want to build a lasting collection? Companies like Loved Again Media offer gently used, curated DVDs—including rare Criterion titles—so you can own the films that matter, without endless searching. Let’s explore how to bring these out-of-print classics home, one spine number at a time.
An Out-of-Print (OOP) Criterion Collection DVD is one that the company has officially ceased producing and distributing. Once a title goes OOP, no new stock is made available on Criterion’s website, through retail partners, or through authorized distributors.
What remains in circulation is whatever was already sold—and that means availability becomes limited to secondhand sellers, collectors, and marketplaces.
The Criterion label applies to both DVDs and Blu-rays. While Blu-ray has largely become the dominant format, many Criterion releases—especially earlier editions—only ever existed on DVD.
For collectors, these editions carry special value not just because of their scarcity, but because they reflect a specific moment in film preservation and presentation history—often complete with essays, restored prints, and director-approved content that may not be reissued again.
The Criterion Collection is renowned for its commitment to preserving important classic and contemporary films. Each release is carefully restored and presented with supplemental material that provides context and insight into the film’s creation, legacy, and meaning.
These extras often include:
There are a few main reasons Criterion DVDs become unavailable:
Out of print Criterion DVDs are more than just discontinued media—they’re collector-grade artifacts that combine rarity, quality, and film history in one shelf-worthy package.
Here’s what makes them so valuable:
Once a Criterion DVD goes out of print, no new copies are produced—ever. This immediately creates a finite supply, especially for titles that had:
As demand remains steady—or even increases—over time, the rarity of these titles drives up their perceived and actual value. Discs that once retailed for $29.99 may now sell for $100+ on secondary markets, especially in mint condition.
This is why collectors often treat Criterion DVDs like investment pieces—because many truly are.
Criterion is known for offering definitive versions of the films it releases. Even when other studios have released the same movie, their editions typically stand apart thanks to:
When a Criterion title goes out of print, the loss isn’t just about access to the film—but the context and craftsmanship that came with that edition. Even if a film returns on another label, it may lack the scholarly depth, production value, or thoughtful extras that Criterion is known for.
Criterion collectors are a dedicated group. Many aim to complete entire sets by spine number (a unique identifier given to every release). Others focus on:
Because many titles are only printed once or twice before disappearing, OOP Criterion DVDs often gain a cult following, even among casual viewers. In particular, cinephiles prize:
Some of the most valuable Criterion OOP DVDs include:
On resale sites, these titles can range from $60 to $400, depending on condition and completeness (disc, case, booklet, and slipcover).
Whether you’re a new collector or a seasoned buyer, spotting these rare editions takes a little research, a sharp eye, and the right resources.
Here’s what to focus on:
Your first stop should always be Criterion’s official site. They maintain a real-time catalog of available DVDs and Blu-rays, and any item that is no longer in print will be clearly marked as “Out of Print.”
Tip: Criterion occasionally runs “Going Out of Print” sales. If you see this label, it means the title is about to become unavailable, and it’s your last chance to buy it new directly from the source.
Keep in mind:
Even if you’re shopping outside the website, several indicators can tell you a DVD is out of print:
You might also find discussions about OOP titles in forums like criterionforum.org or Reddit’s r/criterion, where collectors track discontinued titles in real time.
Out-of-print Criterion DVDs are frequently counterfeited, especially high-demand titles. To make sure you’re getting the real deal, always check for these authenticity markers:
When in doubt, ask the seller for photos of the disc, case, and inserts. A reputable collector or store will have no problem providing this.
In addition to the website, you can verify OOP status using:
Whether you’re building your collection or hunting down a specific OOP title, buying from a reputable seller can save you time and headaches.
These platforms curate gently used DVDs, including rare Criterion titles, and ensure:
From cult classics to major directorial works, here are the OOP Criterion DVDs that consistently draw collectors’ attention.
Some Criterion DVDs are legendary among collectors due to their packaging, bonus features, and the fact that no other editions exist — at least not with the same level of care.
A few examples:
These titles tend to show up only through private sales or niche collectible outlets, often in used but good condition. If you’re lucky enough to spot one in the wild — grab it!
While many Criterion titles have been reissued in upgraded formats, a handful of directors have only one or two releases — and sometimes those go out of print fast.
Here are a few filmmaker-specific releases that collectors hunt for:
Some Criterion DVDs — especially first pressings or box sets — have turned into collectors’ gold. Here’s why certain editions command top dollar:
A few high-value examples often resell for $200–$400+ in mint condition:
Out-of-print Criterion DVDs may no longer be sold new, but that doesn’t mean they’re impossible to find. Knowing where to look — and what to look for — is the key to growing your collection with authentic, collector-grade titles.
These platforms remain popular for locating out-of-print Criterion Collection DVDs. These marketplaces offer a wide variety of listings, from individual titles to entire collections.
Tips for shopping smart:
Niche online shops and independent retailers are goldmines for physical media lovers. These businesses often curate their stock, ensuring condition and authenticity — especially important for Criterion titles.
Some outlets source their inventory from:
Community spaces like Reddit, Blu-ray.com forums, and Facebook collecting groups are fantastic for connecting with fellow Criterion collectors. These groups often:
Not only can you ask questions about specific releases, but you can also get real-world feedback on the condition, pricing, and availability of titles you’re looking for.
These forums are particularly useful for niche interests — like foreign titles, first pressings, or box sets.
For true bargain hunters, don’t overlook library clearance events, secondhand shops, and local thrift stores. Though it’s hit-or-miss, these places occasionally offer surprising finds — including OOP Criterion titles.
Look for:
While the condition can vary, prices are usually low. If you’re willing to restore packaging or clean discs, this is a budget-friendly way to grow your collection.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just getting started, these tips will help you buy smarter, store better, and avoid common pitfalls.
Out-of-print DVDs, especially from the Criterion Collection, are often targeted by counterfeiters. If you’re buying online, take steps to verify authenticity and condition:
If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Rarer titles, especially in good condition, should come with a realistic price tag.
Once you’ve built a collection, proper storage is essential for maintaining disc and packaging quality. Here’s how to keep everything shelf-worthy:
Counterfeit Criterion DVDs are often circulated through auctions and unverified sellers. To avoid adding a fake to your collection:
While collectors value the physical product, making digital backups (for personal use) ensures you always have access to the film — especially for extremely rare or fragile DVDs.
Backing up your out-of-print collection helps you protect against damage or loss, while still enjoying the viewing experience without wear and tear.
While collecting Criterion Collection DVDs is often driven by passion, it also holds potential for long-term value — especially when it comes to out-of-print titles. Whether you’re buying for personal enjoyment or considering the collector’s market, understanding these dynamics can help you make smarter decisions.
When a Criterion DVD goes out of print, scarcity begins to drive value. Titles that once retailed for $29.99 might jump to $80 or more on resale sites once they’re no longer available through official channels.
Some key trends collectors notice:
While some Criterion out-of-print titles have appreciated significantly, collecting DVDs purely as an investment carries risks. Here’s what to consider:
The Rewards:
The Risks:
Also, be cautious about speculating: the majority of Criterion DVDs are meant to be watched and appreciated, not flipped for profit. Still, with the right strategy and curation, your collection can be both personally meaningful and financially rewarding.
Some out-of-print Criterion DVDs are well-known for their long-standing value in the resale market. Examples include:
It depends on your goals. If your main interest is in preserving cinema history and enjoying films with high-quality supplements, out-of-print Criterion DVDs offer lasting value and tangible rewards.
If you’re hoping to build a high-return investment portfolio, be aware of the speculative nature of media collecting. For most fans, the joy comes from owning movies that matter — in the format that honors their artistry.
It doesn’t matter if you’re just starting or fine-tuning your collection; these FAQs will help you navigate how to find, verify, and understand the value of these rare editions.
Some of the most valuable out-of-print Criterion DVDs include titles that were released early in the collection’s history or discontinued due to licensing issues. Examples include:
These titles are prized for their rarity, packaging, and exclusive supplements that haven’t been replicated in newer editions.
There isn’t an official, always-updated public list from Criterion, but there are trusted sources you can use:
Loved Again Media also curates out-of-print Criterion titles in their subscription boxes, helping you discover rare finds with less hunting.
Check if the title is:
You can also search by spine number or edition name on fan databases. Many OOP editions have unique packaging or discontinued artwork.
Yes. You can find out-of-print Criterion titles at:
These sources help you collect safely and sustainably.
Rarity directly influences value. If a Criterion title had:
Criterion DVDs go out of print for several reasons:
The Third Man was discontinued due to licensing — once Criterion lost distribution rights, the DVD was pulled, increasing its value on the resale market.
An Out-of-print Criterion Collection DVD is a unique opportunity to own films that are culturally significant, beautifully presented, and increasingly rare.
Can’t wait to own one? Loved Again Media helps you to reconnect with hard-to-find DVDs, including out-of-print Criterion editions, all hand-selected, gently used, and delivered with care.
Explore curated boxes or dive into rare finds that match your taste and preserve film history—one disc at a time. Subscribe now!
Choosing a movie shouldn’t take longer than watching one. If you want hand-picked movie collections delivered, you’re probably done with endless scrolling
Finding deep cut movies on disc shouldn’t feel like an endless hunt through bad listings and inflated prices. If streaming never serves
Trying to find an eco-friendly way to build a movie collection can feel impossible when new releases mean more plastic and more
